The Hive bee sealUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveThe people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not any party or special interest.
Referendum Docket · RF 000.02← All referendums tracked · ← Hive library (every repo)
Statewide · Legislative History

The Rules Keep Changing: How Utah's Referendum Law Got Harder to Use

Utah was the second state in the nation to adopt citizen referendum, in 1900. Over the last two decades, and especially since 2019, the Legislature has repeatedly rewritten the rules for using it — raising signature thresholds, adding geographic distribution requirements, tightening petition procedure, and extending two-thirds immunity to more kinds of decisions. Bills that would have made referendums easier to use have generally died.

UTAH CODE TITLE 20A, CHAPTER 7 KEY CHANGES: 2019, 2022, 2023
Statewide

Posted Sept. 18, 2026 · Updated Oct. 18, 2026 · Page look updated Nov. 2, 2026

Published Sept. 18, 2026 · Updated Oct. 1, 2026: added a large-print diagram of today's local referendum hurdles, a section on 2026 Constitutional Amendment B, a "People in this record" table, source links, a corrected official title for H.B. 119, and a "Two Kinds of Ballot Signatures" section.

Part 1 of 2: How it works, and the laws that changed it

New to this? Read it in plain words About 300 words, with simple charts.
Referendum docket pages (7) · tap to open
  1. Referendum docketEvery referendum the Hive tracks, searchable
  2. Eagle Mountain's Second Tax Referendum · plain wordsThe fight over a ballot date and the city's pamphlet
  3. Eagle Mountain's Finance History · plain wordsWhere the property tax goes before the General Fund
  4. Roy Prop 10 · plain wordsKeep or reject a $1.75 million tax increase
  5. Uintah County Prop 9 · plain wordsWhether to replace the county commission
  6. Two Referendums, Zero Votes · plain wordsBox Elder's Stratos fight and Summit County's Kimball Junction
  7. The Rules Keep Changing · Part 2 · plain wordsHow Utah's referendum law got harder to use

The short version

  • Utah adopted the citizen referendum in 1900. Since 2019 especially, the Legislature has rewritten the rules for using it.
  • H.B. 119 (2019) created a separate, higher signature threshold for land-use referendums and a rule that signatures come from at least 75% of voter participation areas.
  • H.B. 218 (2022) and H.B. 38 (2023) tightened petition procedure, and a two-thirds immunity rule was extended to some local land-use decisions.
  • Every bill in this record that would have made referendums easier to use died. Every bill that made the process harder passed.
  • Constitutional Amendment B on the Nov. 3, 2026 ballot is about initiatives, not referendums: it would require 60% approval for citizen-proposed laws that raise taxes.
1900
Referendum right adopted
16%
Land-use signature bar, first-class counties
75%
Of voter participation areas must be reached
60%
Amendment B's proposed vote for tax initiatives
New Here? The Short Version

Utah's citizen referendum right is old — written into the state constitution in 1900. How easy it is to actually use has changed a lot more recently, and the record is one-sided. In 2019, the Legislature overhauled the local referendum process, creating a separate and much higher signature threshold for land-use referendums specifically, plus a new geographic-distribution rule. In 2022 and 2023, follow-up bills tightened petition-packet procedure and extended a two-thirds-vote immunity rule to certain local land-use decisions. All of those passed. Meanwhile, every bill found in this record that would have made a referendum easier to use or more effective — a 2006 and a 2013 bill that would have stayed a challenged law while its referendum was pending, a 2022 bill that would have lowered the 2019 thresholds, and a 2025 bill that would have created a brand-new referendum right over school-board tax decisions — died. Three of those four died the same specific way: the Senate or House struck its own enacting clause rather than holding a recorded floor vote on the substance. This piece lays out the record, bill by bill.

Where This Is

Every referendum on the Hive docket. The gold line is the state; dark lines are counties; dashed purple lines are city limits. Zoom in for more labels.

Eagle Mountain tax referendum (not on the Nov. 3 ballot) · Roy Prop 10 (printed on the Nov. 3 ballot) · Uintah County Prop 9 (on the Nov. 3 ballot) · Box Elder County: Stratos referendum (in court) · Summit County: Kimball Junction referendum (closed)
See every Utah referendum the Hive tracks on MAP 006: Citizen Referendums →

How a Local Referendum Works Today

A referendum is when voters ask to undo a law their city or county already passed. Here are the hurdles a local land-use referendum faces today, and the bill (or court rulings) that put each one there. The order is simplified; every step comes from the sections below.

Each box is one hurdle. The bill that added it is in the box.

flowchart TD
  A["Council passes
a law"] --> B{"Land-use law,
unanimous or 2/3
(transit area)?"} B -->|Yes| X["No referendum
allowed
S.B. 199 (2023)"] B -->|No| C{"Legislative, not
administrative?
(court rulings)"} C -->|No| X C -->|Yes| D["10-day notice;
numbered, bound
packets
H.B. 38 (2023)"] D --> E["Signers must be
registered first
H.B. 218 (2022)"] E --> F["Higher land-use
signature bar,
spread by area
H.B. 119 (2019)"] F --> G["Law goes to
the voters"]

The two-thirds and unanimous paths are in Utah Code 20A-7-602.8 (Section 4). The "legislative vs. administrative" test comes from court cases, not a bill (Section 5). The signature bar is 16% of active voters for first-class counties and up to 40% for towns, with signatures spread across at least 75% of voter participation areas in larger places (Section 1).

1. The 2019 Overhaul: H.B. 119

H.B. 119 ("Initiatives, Referenda, and Other Political Activities," primary sponsor Rep. Brad Daw, Senate sponsor Sen. Curtis Bramble) is the single biggest rewrite of local referendum law in this record. Before it, signature thresholds were calculated as a percentage of the prior presidential-election vote count. The bill switched the base to "active voters" as of a fixed date set annually by the Lieutenant Governor's office — and, more consequentially, created an entirely separate, higher threshold specifically for referendums against land-use decisions.

Signature threshold, first-class counties: general law vs. land-use law
General-law referendum
7.5–7.75%
Land-use referendum
16%

For towns, the gap is even wider: up to 40% of active voters for a land-use referendum vs. 35% for a general-law one. Source: HB 119 (2019), le.utah.gov.

64–7–4House 3rd reading, 3/5/2019
21–1–7Senate 2nd/3rd reading, 3/14/2019
59–12–4House concurrence, 3/14/2019
Ch. 203Signed 3/25/2019 · effective 5/14/2019

H.B. 119 passed both chambers by lopsided margins in every recorded vote — this was not a close or contested floor fight, whatever friction it caused afterward among referendum sponsors dealing with the new thresholds.

Why land use specifically Contemporaneous reporting (Deseret News, March 2019) traces the bill to two specific fights: the Provo-Orem bus rapid transit project and the Cottonwood Mall housing redevelopment controversy. Both were land-use disputes where opponents had used or threatened a referendum.

The same bill created the Voter Participation Area (VPA) system: jurisdictions above a population threshold must be divided into 8 (or 4, for mid-size jurisdictions) contiguous areas, and referendum signatures must be distributed across at least 75% of those areas — not just added up citywide. A raw signature total large enough to clear the percentage threshold can still fail if it's concentrated in too few VPAs.

Direct line to a live case This VPA requirement is the same "street-level boundary information" sponsors of Eagle Mountain's 2026 tax referendum have been requesting from the city and say they haven't received in an updated form — see the Eagle Mountain case file, Section 3.

2. Locking Down the Petition Process: H.B. 218 (2022) & H.B. 38 (2023)

Two follow-up bills tightened the mechanics of running a signature drive, on top of the 2019 thresholds.

BillWhat it changedVote
H.B. 218 (2022)
"Ballot Measure Amendments"
Rep. Jordan Teuscher / Sen. Jerry Stevenson
Added electronic signature-gathering as an option, but also tightened voter eligibility — removed the option for signers who merely intended to register before certification (must now be currently registered) — and expanded public posting of signer data.House 68-0-7 (3rd reading, 2/15/2022); Senate 28-0-1 (2nd/3rd reading, 3/2/2022); House concurrence 71-0-4 (3/3/2022); signed 3/24/2022; Chapter 325, eff. 1/1/2023
H.B. 38 (2023)
"Initiative and Referendum Modifications"
Rep. Calvin Musselman / Sen. David Buxton
Lengthened required public-hearing notice from 3 to 10 days; required sponsors to submit hearing video/audio/minutes before receiving signature sheets; formalized a sponsor-signed packet-numbering agreement — the administrative predicate for the strict packet-binding rules.70-0-5 (House), 25-0-4 (Senate)
Direct line to a live case The packet-binding formality this framework created is the same kind of rule that disqualified most of the petition packets in Summit County's 2025 Kimball Junction referendum — organizers gathered over 6,000 signatures, well above the 4,554 required, but a binding-format issue left only about 3,214 certified as valid. See the companion piece for the full sequence.
A different kind of committee record H.B. 218 started life titled "Citizen Petition Amendments" before its name changed. Confirmed directly against both committee minutes: it passed the House Political Subdivisions Committee 10-0-0 and the Senate Government Operations and Political Subdivisions Committee 5-0-2, with every witness who spoke — a county sheriff, the Lt. Governor's Elections Director, and Weber County Clerk/Auditor Ricky Hatch (chair of the Clerks Legislative Committee) — speaking in favor, not against. No opposition testimony is recorded for this bill in either chamber, unlike H.B. 408 (2025) below.

3. When Signature Gatherers Were Charged or Accused of Fraud

The petition-procedure tightening covered above (H.B. 218, H.B. 38) is usually framed around protecting the process from outside interference. But the criminal charges and fraud allegations filed in Utah in recent years have involved people working inside the paid-signature-gathering industry itself — companies hired by campaigns and committees to collect the signatures that get a candidate on the ballot or a measure in front of voters.

Charged, March 2025

Gathering Inc.

Hired by 2024 candidate campaigns, including Gov. Spencer Cox’s. News reports also named U.S. Senate candidate Brad Wilson and state Sen. Don Ipson among its 2024 clients. Most charging documents do not say which candidate each defendant was gathering for. The Utah Attorney General's Office charged 11 people who worked as circulators for the firm with forgery, communication fraud, and breach of certificate-of-nomination procedures. According to the charging documents, one circulator had 2,146 of 2,243 submitted signatures rejected; another had an 80% invalidation rate; and investigators wrote that several told them they let spouses sign for each other or signed names themselves to increase their per-signature pay. County clerks flagged the packets during verification.

Utah AG charges filed 3/10/2025 · 11 defendants

Charged

Battleground USA LLC

A separate case tied to the 2022 2nd Congressional District signature-gathering effort for candidate Bruce Hough. Owner Daniel Jacob McWilliams was paid over $58,000 for the contract; 13 people were charged. Prosecutors alleged circulators used Nevada residents despite Utah residency requirements, falsified verification forms, and created false lease documents and text messages before the packets were submitted to the Lieutenant Governor's office.

13 defendants charged

Alleged, Feb. 2026 — deadline missed

Patriot Grassroots

A Wyoming-based firm paid over $4.3 million to gather signatures for the 2026 effort to repeal Proposition 4 (Utah's 2018 voter-approved anti-gerrymandering law), on behalf of Utahns for Representative Government, the Republican-backed committee chaired by state GOP chairman Rob Axson. Donald Trump Jr. publicly promoted the firm and urged followers to sign on as gatherers. Utah County Clerk Aaron Davidson called the resulting packets "probably the most extensive fraud that we've seen," citing fabricated names and addresses, duplicate signers, and packets missing the required initiative text; 27 packets were referred for criminal investigation. Axson's committee terminated Patriot Grassroots' contract, but the campaign fell far short of the ~140,679 signatures required and missed its Feb. 15, 2026 deadline.

Utah County referred 27 packets for investigation · campaign missed deadline

Charged is not convicted All three cases above reflect charges filed or fraud alleged by county/state officials, not final court judgments; check current docket status before describing any of these as a conviction. One defendant in the Gathering Inc. case is reported to have accepted a plea deal, but the terms weren't independently confirmed in this research.
A name worth watching Gathering Inc. is a signature-gathering company documented elsewhere in this outlet's reporting as controlled by Casey Hill, a registered Utah lobbyist and co-founder of Lincoln Hill Partners/PAC with a long client roster spanning both major statewide campaigns and corporate lobbying work. That prior reporting is a separate research thread from this piece and should be independently re-confirmed against the corporate registry before the two are linked in print.

4. Two-Thirds Immunity: 1900 to Now

The rule that a law passed by a two-thirds vote of each legislative chamber cannot be referred to voters at all is not new — it's in Utah Constitution Article VI, Section 1, part of the original 1900 amendment that created the referendum right in the first place. It survived a full rewrite of Article VI in 1972 and a renumbering in 2000 without substantive change.

What is new: extending a version of that immunity down to the local level. S.B. 199 (2023), "Local Land Use Amendments" (Sen. Mike McKell), amended Utah Code 20A-7-602.8 to exempt a "transit area land use law" passed by a two-thirds vote from local referendum. McKell said in press coverage that referendums had been "weaponized" against housing developers. Confirmed directly against the current statutory text (20A-7-602.8): the two-thirds carve-out is exactly that narrow, scoped to transit area land use law — but the same section contains a second, separate immunity mechanism that earlier coverage of this bill didn't flag: a "municipal land use law" is independently exempt from local referendum if it passes by a unanimous vote of the local legislative body, with no "transit area" limitation. That is a lower bar to invoke procedurally (any council can vote unanimously on an uncontroversial-seeming item) even though it requires full agreement rather than two-thirds.

1900Two-thirds immunity written into the state constitution
2023S.B. 199 adds two local-level immunity paths under 20A-7-602.8
Two separate local immunity paths, not one 20A-7-602.8 now exempts local land-use law from referendum two different ways: (1) a transit area land use law passed by a two-thirds vote, and (2) a municipal land use law passed by a unanimous vote. Neither requires the underlying project to be small or uncontroversial — only that the council reach the specified vote margin. A unanimous council vote is arguably easier to engineer on a fast-tracked item than a two-thirds vote on a genuinely contested one, which makes the unanimous-vote path worth watching in any project where a council moves quickly and without dissent.

5. The Judicial Backdrop: "Administrative" vs. "Legislative"

Separately from anything the Legislature has passed, Utah courts have long held that only a local government's "legislative" acts — new laws of general applicability — can be sent to voters by referendum. Its "administrative" acts, applying existing policy to a specific situation, generally cannot. This distinction comes from case law, not statute, though the Legislature has since cross-referenced categories of it in Utah Code 20A-7-102 and 20A-7-602.8.

Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism

The Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.

Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us

Reporting from public records only — no outreach to referendum subjects.

We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.

All referendums tracked · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack