Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveThe people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not any party or special interest.
← All Nuclear Energy pages  ·  Hive library ↗
Docket · NRC, DOE and the Department of War · NE 200.01

The Federal Permits

A DOE categorical exclusion from full environmental review, a military airlift, and a new NRC rule that lets commercial licenses reuse DOE and military reviews. Here is what each federal record says, and what it says about the public.

Posted Oct. 29, 2026 · Updated Oct. 29, 2026

The short version

WHERE
Federal · NRC, Department of Energy, Department of War, Bureau of Land Management · Utah sites: Emery County, Carbon County, Hill AFB, Tooele
WHO
Nov. 25
the day the NRC rule reusing DOE and military reviews takes effect
136
comments the NRC received; an earlier check found none from the State of Utah
0
Utah military bases named in Army or Air Force reactor programs, in the records searched

How a reactor gets approved now

flowchart LR
A["Department of Energy
or Department of War
authorizes a test reactor"] --> B["DOE categorical
exclusion (B5.26)
no full environmental review"] B --> C["Reactor is built
and tested
(Ward 250, Emery County)"] C --> D["Company asks the NRC
for a commercial license"] D --> E["NRC may reuse the
DOE or military review
(new rule, Nov. 25)"]
Each box is a step documented in the federal records listed below. The NRC still issues the commercial license.

The federal record, item by item

AgencyRecordDateWhat it does
NRCFinal rule adding 10 CFR 50.43(f), Docket NRC-2025-1503Approved Oct. 22; published Oct. 26; takes effect Nov. 25, 2026A commercial license application may use information from a reactor the Department of Energy or Department of War already authorized and tested
DOECategorical exclusion B5.26, "Advanced nuclear reactors"Effective Feb. 2, 2026Lets DOE authorize, site, build and run advanced reactors without a full environmental review when it finds the risk low enough
DOECX-271015, "Valar Ward250 Research Reactor" (DOE-ID-26-005)2026Used that exclusion for Valar's test reactor at the San Rafael lab in Emery County
DOEReactor Pilot Program (DE-FOA-0003569)Selections Aug. 12, 2025Test reactors "authorized by DOE ... at sites outside the national laboratories"; companies pay all costs
DOEFuel Line Pilot ProgramValar selected Sept. 30, 2025TRISO fuel made on site "for the Ward250 reactor deployment"
Air Force"Operation Windlord" (name per af.mil)Feb. 15, 2026The Ward 250 reactor was loaded on a C-17 at March Air Reserve Base, Calif., and flown to Hill Air Force Base, then taken on to the lab. The Air Force article describes one C-17; Stars and Stripes reported three
NRCValar engagement plan, ML26274A394Apr. 2, 2026Valar: it "does not currently have plans to submit an NRC application." Plan withheld from the public at Valar's request
NRCWeekly report SECY-26-0111Filing Aug. 10, 2026Valar's revised plan, "outlining plans to seek NRC licensing"; NRC staff offered to observe DOE's review of a "second test reactor, NumenorOne"
Federal courtTexas et al. v. NRC, No. 6:24-cv-00507 (E.D. Tex.)Filed Dec. 30, 2024The State of Utah and Valar are plaintiffs seeking to change how small reactors are licensed. The American Nuclear Society reported (Oct. 5, 2026) that the states filed to drop the case. We could not open the court docket to confirm.
BLM"Project Beehive" land application, about 9,000 acres near PriceReported Sept. 30, 2026BLM says it is "currently reviewing the application for completeness." No serial number found in a federal record
DOENuclear Lifecycle Innovation CampusFinalists July 28, 2026Utah is one of five finalist states; non-binding agreements signed

The new NRC rule, in its own words

The rule says an application "may include consideration of relevant information gathered from a utilization facility that has been previously authorized by the Department of Energy or the Department of Defense and that has been tested and has demonstrated the ability to function safely. Any reference to such a design must identify how attributes of the authorization satisfy NRC regulations ..."

The NRC says it "will not need to repeat technical reviews previously performed by DOE or DOW ... to the extent that those reviews cover the same scope." It also says "Nothing in this rule delegates to DOE, DOW, or any other agency the NRC's functions" and that it "was not able to quantify these potential savings in a useful way at this time."

Who commented

The NRC's full answers to the 136 comments are in document ML26282A996. We have not read it yet.

DOE's categorical exclusion for advanced reactors

DOE's exclusion B5.26 took effect the day it was published, Feb. 2, 2026. DOE then took 30 days of comment, which it called voluntary. Attorneys general from 11 states and D.C. objected on Mar. 4, writing that "DOE's process to promulgate this CE included no public participation in advance of the effective date" and that "DOE has no authority to authorize commercial power generation or industrial application." Utah did not sign.

The Ward 250 form (CX-271015) says "the proposed action is hereby categorically excluded from further NEPA review." It describes a 250-kilowatt-thermal reactor on about 2 acres of a 20.6-acre site, run for about 12 months, then 6 months of cooldown and 6 of decommissioning. It has no public notice or comment language. The Utah historic preservation office "concurs that no historic properties will be affected."

The reactor's size doesn't match from record to record. DOE's form says 250 kilowatts thermal. Valar's quality description, as reported, says 100 kilowatts "initial test power." The American Nuclear Society reported 10 kilowatts on June 22. The Air Force article calls it "a 5-megawatt nuclear reactor." DOE called the June 18 test "zero-power"; an earlier Hive page recorded the state lab's site calling it "full-power." We report them side by side.

Public hearings are changing too

The other side, from the same records: the NRC says the right to request a contested hearing is unchanged and the new rule does not lower its safety standard. BLM says the public will get input on Valar's land request through the federal environmental review. TerraPower's Wyoming permit and Holtec's Michigan application went through standard NRC notice and hearing steps.

The military

Hill Air Force Base appears in the record only as the stop where the Ward 250 reactor landed. The Army's nine candidate sites, its Janus program awards (Aug. 26, 2026, five bases) and the Air Force's first microreactor sites name no Utah installation.

At Hill AFB on Feb. 15, 2026, Under Secretary of War Michael Duffey said: "It's clear to me that advancing President Trump's priority on nuclear energy depends on close coordination between the Department of Energy and the Department of War." The Air Force article reports, in its own words, that he said the future of warfare is energy-intensive and includes AI data centers, and that the War Department will need to build its own energy infrastructure.

Where this connects

Questions to ask, and to whom

Sources and how we read them ▾

How we read these records: most documents were read as text through a reading tool on Oct. 29, 2026, not as rendered pages. Short quotes are marked; check any quote against the original before reusing it. "Not found in the records searched" means we looked and did not find it, not that it does not exist.

  1. NRC final rule, RIN 3150-AL60, Docket NRC-2025-1503, 91 FR 67195 (Oct. 26, 2026); NRC copy ML26295A067; NRC news release 26-081
  2. Proposed rule, Federal Register, Apr. 2, 2026; comment responses ML26282A996 (not yet read)
  3. Comments: New York (NYSERDA, May 4, 2026); Beyond Nuclear/NIRS joint letter incl. Uranium Watch (May 4, 2026); Valar (NRC-2025-1503-0010); HEAL Utah (-0091); Oregon Dept. of Energy — via regulations.gov docket NRC-2025-1503 (some read in an Oct. 24–25 session and not re-opened)
  4. DOE categorical exclusion B5.26, 91 FR 4550; attorneys general letter, Mar. 4, 2026
  5. DOE CX-271015, Valar Ward250 Research Reactor. Text extraction drops the signature field; an Oct. 2026 check of the rendered form found it signed.
  6. DOE Reactor Pilot Program; DOE release, June 18, 2026; World Nuclear News
  7. Air Force Reserve Command, Operation Windlord (Feb. 17, 2026)
  8. NRC ML26274A394 (Valar letter, Apr. 2, 2026); SECY-26-0111, ML26243A397 (Sept. 2, 2026)
  9. State of Texas et al. v. NRC, No. 6:24-cv-00507 (E.D. Tex.); American Nuclear Society Nuclear Newswire (docket not opened)
  10. NPR/KUER (Sept. 30, 2026) and East Idaho News/Utah News Dispatch (Oct. 1, 2026) on Project Beehive
  11. NRC hearing changes: 91 FR 20063 (Apr. 15, 2026); 91 FR 34661 (June 8, 2026); 91 FR 10450 (Mar. 3, 2026); NRC-2025-1140, 91 FR 43456 (July 15, 2026); GAO-26-108737 (Sept. 28, 2026); S. 1757; S. 4284
  12. Army Janus awards (Aug. 26, 2026); DOE campus finalists release (July 28, 2026)
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism

The Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.

Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us

We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.

Nuclear Energy shelf · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack