- Who is suing: League of Women Voters of Utah, Mormon Women for Ethical Government and six voters.
- Who is being sued: The Utah State Legislature, its redistricting committee, Sen. Scott Sandall, Rep. Mike Schultz, Sen. J. Stuart Adams, and Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson (official capacities).
- Lawyers: Plaintiffs: Zimmerman Booher, Parr Brown, Campaign Legal Center. Legislature: Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel, Consovoy McCarthy. Lt. Gov.: Attorney General's Office.
- The judges: Dianna Gibson until February 2026; then a three-judge panel of Catherine Conklin, Derek Williams and Roger Griffin.
In plain words (explain it like I'm 10)
Every 10 years, the lines for congressional districts get redrawn. In 2018, voters passed Prop 4 to set fair-drawing rules. Lawmakers later replaced it with their own law. Voters' groups sued. The Utah Supreme Court said lawmakers can't freely undo a voter initiative that reforms government, and a judge later picked a new map. The case is still going, now over a new law that moved it to a three-judge court.
The short version
- July 11, 2024: the Utah Supreme Court ruled 5-0 that "government-reform initiatives are constitutionally protected from unfettered legislative amendment, repeal, or replacement."
- Aug. 25, 2025: Judge Gibson ruled the repeal of Prop 4 unconstitutional and blocked the 2021 map.
- Nov. 10, 2025: she rejected the Legislature's "Map C," finding it "was drawn with the purpose to favor Republicans," and adopted the plaintiffs' Map 1, which was used in 2026.
- 2026: a new law (H.B. 392) moved the case to a three-judge panel. The plaintiffs argue that panel is unconstitutional; the Utah Supreme Court heard arguments Oct. 5, 2026, with no ruling yet.
Timeline
Dates from court records and news coverage listed in Sources.
flowchart TD A["2018
Voters pass Prop 4"] --> B["2020
Legislature passes S.B. 200"] B --> C["March 17, 2022
Lawsuit filed"] C --> D["July 11, 2024
Supreme Court: initiatives
protected, 5-0"] D --> E["Aug. 25, 2025
Repeal ruled unconstitutional"] E --> F["Nov. 10, 2025
Map 1 adopted"] F --> G["Feb. 2026
Case moved to
three-judge panel"] G --> H["Oct. 5, 2026
Supreme Court hears
panel challenge"]
- 2018Voters pass Prop 4.
- 2020The Legislature repeals it and passes S.B. 200 (Campaign Legal Center).
- March 17, 2022Complaint filed, Third District No. 220901712.
- July 11, 2024Utah Supreme Court, 2024 UT 21, written by Justice Petersen, 5-0: "we reverse the district court's dismissal of Count V."
- Aug. 25, 2025Judge Gibson rules the repeal unconstitutional and reinstates Prop 4 (KUER). She amended it Sept. 9 to remove the order requiring the Legislature to redraw.
- Oct. 6, 2025Legislature passes S.B. 1011 and S.B. 1012 ("Map C"); the governor signs both (Loyola).
- Nov. 10, 2025Judge Gibson rejects Map C and adopts Map 1 (KPCW/KUER).
- Feb. 13, 2026H.B. 392 moves pending cases to new three-judge courts; this case went to one Feb. 26 (Loyola).
- Feb. 20, 2026Utah Supreme Court dismisses the Legislature's appeal for lack of a final judgment, without reaching the merits (KUER).
- Feb. 23, 2026A federal three-judge panel denies Reps. Owens and Maloy's request to block the map; they later dismissed their suit (KSL).
- March 17, 2026The three-judge panel denies the plaintiffs' TRO motion as moot (Loyola).
- July 8, 2026Supreme Court agrees to hear the plaintiffs' appeal of that denial (No. 20260365).
- Oct. 5, 2026Seven-justice court hears the challenge to the three-judge panel law, listed on the court's October 2026 calendar as "League of Women Voters v. Utah State Legislature #20260236" (Utah Courts calendar; KUER).
- Oct. 19, 2026Plaintiffs file their principal brief.
What each side says
| Question | League of Women Voters et al. | Utah Legislature |
|---|---|---|
| Can the Legislature replace Prop 4? | Not freely; government-reform initiatives are protected. | The Legislature "is still seeking to overturn a 2024 state Supreme Court ruling" (KSL, July 10, 2026). |
| Was Map C fair? | No; it favored Republicans. | Passed it with new standards in S.B. 1011. |
| The three-judge panel | It "is unconstitutional because its creation violated (a) Article V and Article VIII" (brief). | "There may be some line beyond which the Legislature can't pass when it's talking about an amendment" (Tyler Green at argument, KUER). |
What court rulings and records confirm
- Judge Gibson, Aug. 25, 2025: "The nature of the violation lies in the Legislature's refusal to respect the people's exercise" (KUER).
- Judge Gibson, Nov. 10, 2025: "In short, Map C does not comply with Utah law" (KPCW/KUER).
- The Feb. 20, 2026 Supreme Court order said the appeal was "improper and we lack jurisdiction" (KUER).
- Map 1, with a Democratic-leaning district in northern Salt Lake County, was used for 2026 (KUER; KSL).
- The GOP-led initiative to repeal Prop 4 did not qualify for the 2026 ballot after signature withdrawals (Ballotpedia).
Claims no court has decided
These are what a party says in its filings. They are not findings.
- The plaintiffs argue the three-judge panel law is unconstitutional. The Supreme Court has not ruled.
- A separate Feb. 23, 2026 suit by Utahns for Representative Government alleged Better Boundaries' prepaid postage was improper. No ruling was found.
People connected to the record
Where this connects
- GC 009: Amendment DThe Legislature's 2024 constitutional amendment response, voided in this same case.
- Amendment B case file (Transparency repo)Related fights over citizen initiatives.
What we don't know yet
- What the other 2026 Utah Supreme Court case numbers (20251057, 20260019, 20260237) cover.
- When the Supreme Court will rule on the three-judge panel law.
- Final certified 2026 congressional results under Map 1.
Questions to ask, and whom to ask
- Utah Legislature: How much has the state spent on outside counsel in this case?
- Utah Supreme Court (docket): When will the court rule on the three-judge panel challenge?
- Voters: Who should draw district lines: lawmakers, a commission, or courts?
Words to know
Help cover records costs
Public records aren't always free. The Hive Records Fund helps pay records fees, copies and other costs behind pages like this one. You pick the amount, and every dollar in and every cost paid is listed publicly. The Weber County Hive is not a nonprofit, so contributions are not tax-deductible.
Behind this piece
Built from court records and news reports listed below.
Sources
Sources — click to open (with links)
- Utah Supreme Court, 2024 UT 21 (July 11, 2024)
- All About Redistricting (Loyola) case page
- Campaign Legal Center case page (Oct. 20, 2026)
- Appellants' principal brief (Oct. 19, 2026)
- KUER (Aug. 25, 2025)
- KPCW/KUER (Nov. 11, 2025)
- KUER (Feb. 20, 2026)
- KUER (Oct. 5, 2026)
- Utah Supreme Court oral argument calendar, October 2026
- KSL (July 10, 2026)
- Ballotpedia News (March 28, 2026)

