- Who sued: League of Women Voters of Utah, Mormon Women for Ethical Government and others, in the same case as GC 008.
- What was challenged: S.J.R. 401 (Amendment D), 2024 Fourth Special Session; primary sponsor Sen. Kirk Cullimore, floor sponsor Rep. Jordan Teuscher.
- The vote in the Legislature: Passed Aug. 21, 2024: Senate 20-8-1, House 54-21-0.
- The judges: Judge Dianna Gibson (Third District); all five Utah Supreme Court justices.
In plain words (explain it like I'm 10)
To change Utah's constitution, lawmakers must publish the change in a newspaper in every county for two months and describe it honestly on the ballot. The courts said Amendment D did neither, so votes on it were not counted. Voters later approved a change to that newspaper rule in 2026.
The short version
- Sept. 12, 2024: Judge Gibson ruled Amendment D "is void and shall be given no effect." Ballots were already printed, so votes on it were not counted.
- Sept. 25, 2024: the Utah Supreme Court unanimously agreed: "neither constitutional prerequisite was met with respect to Amendment D."
- Oct. 24, 2024 opinion (Justice Hagen): "We simply cannot read the word 'newspaper' out of the Publication Clause."
- What followed: 2026's Amendment A (H.J.R. 10) replaced the newspaper-in-every-county rule with publication "in a manner provided by statute." The AP called it passed Nov. 5, 2026 (KUER).
Timeline
Dates from court records and news coverage listed in Sources.
flowchart TD A["July 11, 2024
Prop 4 ruling"] --> B["Aug. 21, 2024
Legislature passes
Amendment D"] B --> C["Sept. 5, 2024
Challenge filed"] C --> D["Sept. 12, 2024
Judge voids it"] D --> E["Sept. 25, 2024
Supreme Court agrees, 5-0"] E --> F["Oct. 24, 2024
Formal opinion"] F --> G["Nov. 2026
Voters pass Amendment A"]
- July 11, 2024Utah Supreme Court's Prop 4 ruling (see GC 008).
- Aug. 21, 2024Legislature passes S.J.R. 401 (Amendment D).
- Sept. 5, 2024Plaintiffs file a supplemental complaint and motion to block it (Democracy Docket).
- Sept. 12, 2024Judge Gibson grants a preliminary injunction; the Legislature "has the duty and the obligation to accurately communicate the 'subject matter'" (KSL).
- Sept. 25, 2024Supreme Court affirms, per curiam and unanimous (FindLaw; FOX 13).
- Oct. 24, 2024Formal opinion by Justice Hagen: League of Women Voters of Utah v. Utah State Legislature, 2024 UT 40, No. 20240965 (opinion filed Oct. 24, 2024; heard Sept. 25, 2024).
- Feb.-March 2025H.J.R. 10 passes the House 70-0 and the Senate 29-0 (Ballotpedia).
- Nov. 3-5, 20262026 Amendment A passes with about 60% in preliminary results; the AP called it Nov. 5 (KSL; KUER).
What each side says
| Question | Plaintiffs | Legislature |
|---|---|---|
| Was it properly published? | No newspaper publication in each county for two months. | The Legislature's argument on this point is in the opinion; not summarized here. |
| Was the ballot language accurate? | It misled voters about what the amendment did. | Leaders called the lower court ruling "policymaking action from the bench." |
| After the ruling | Votes on Amendment D not counted. | Leaders called the Supreme Court's order "unprecedented and troubling." |
What court rulings and records confirm
- ¶9: "posting a public notice on a government website does not meet our constitution's express requirements."
- ¶79: "if the ballot title would mislead a reasonable voter as to what they are voting for or against, the proposed amendment has not been submitted to the voters as the constitution requires."
- ¶96: "the Legislature did not submit the true amendment to voters."
- Ballotpedia reports both the 2024 Amendment A and Amendment D were voided over the newspaper publication requirement.
Claims no court has decided
These are what a party says in its filings. They are not findings.
- None outstanding on Amendment D. The wider case continues as GC 008.
People connected to the record
Where this connects
- GC 008: the Prop 4 caseThe same lawsuit, before and after Amendment D.
- Amendment B case file (Transparency repo)The 2026 initiative amendment.
What we don't know yet
- Whether the broader case has any separate closing entry on the docket for Amendment D.
- Final certified totals for 2026 Amendment A (due Nov. 23, 2026).
Questions to ask, and whom to ask
- Utah Legislature: Under the new Amendment A, what does the statute now require for publishing proposed amendments?
- Lieutenant Governor's Office: Where will voters find the full text of future amendments, and for how long before an election?
Words to know
Help cover records costs
Public records aren't always free. The Hive Records Fund helps pay records fees, copies and other costs behind pages like this one. You pick the amount, and every dollar in and every cost paid is listed publicly. The Weber County Hive is not a nonprofit, so contributions are not tax-deductible.
Behind this piece
Built from court records and news reports listed below.
Sources
Sources — click to open (with links)
- Utah Supreme Court order (Sept. 25, 2024), FindLaw
- Utah Supreme Court opinion, 2024 UT 40 (Oct. 24, 2024), hosted by State Court Report
- Utah Supreme Court opinion (Oct. 24, 2024), FindLaw
- FOX 13 (Sept. 25, 2024)
- FOX 13 (Oct. 24, 2024)
- KSL: judge blocks Amendment D (Sept. 2024)
- S.J.R. 401 (2024 Fourth Special Session)
- Ballotpedia: 2026 publication requirements measure
- KUER: 2026 results (updated Nov. 5, 2026)

