- Who is suing: Wolf Creek Resort Holdings, et al. Shane Dunleavy is named as one of the owners (KSL).
- Who is being sued: The Wolf Creek Water and Sewer Improvement District, et al.
- Lawyers: For the developers' related company EVO: Parr Brown and Bruce R. Baird PLLC. Letters for the district came from Cohne Kinghorn.
- What they want: At least $2.5 million for water shares and at least $17 million in lost development, at least $19.5 million total (KSL).
- Planned projects: 331 homes, 292 condos and townhomes, a hotel and 60,000 square feet of commercial space (KSL).
In plain words (explain it like I'm 10)
To build houses, you need water for them. In Eden, a small local district runs the water. Developers say the district wouldn't give them water service, so they couldn't build, and they want money for that. The district says it only has one well for drinking water and has to protect the people already using it. A judge hasn't decided.
The short version
- Filed May 5, 2025, in Second District Court, Civil No. 250903485 (KSL; Weber County Board of Adjustment packet).
- The claim: the developers say the district improperly refused to secure water rights for their projects. Dunleavy: the district is "weaponizing their control of water to block development."
- The district: it has one culinary source, the Warm Springs well, which "has greatly limited our options." It moved to dismiss June 13, 2025, saying the parties' contracts control.
- Other figures: letters in a county board packet describe $54.5 million two ways: the district's lawyer ties it to this case, and the developers' letter describes two cases together. The district's March 10, 2026 letter to customers says developers are suing for "more than $45M." None of these is a court-confirmed current demand.
Timeline
Dates from court records and news coverage listed in Sources.
flowchart TD A["May 5, 2025
Developers sue district"] --> B["June 13, 2025
District moves to dismiss"] B --> C["June 13, 2025
Second developer sues"] C --> D["Oct. 23, 2025
Will-serve appeal withdrawn
at county board"] D --> E["2026
District board meets in
closed session on legal action"]
- May 5, 2025Wolf Creek Resort Holdings sues the district (KSL photo caption).
- May 8, 2025District statement: it is "saddened by the additional lawsuit" and will "fight for the rights of our current customers" (KSL).
- June 13, 2025District files a motion to dismiss (KSL/Deseret, July 3). Separately, P.C. Luminary (Powder Canyon at Wolf Creek) sues the same district.
- Aug.-Sept. 2025Letters between lawyers, printed in the Weber County Board of Adjustment packet, cite Case No. 250903485.
- Oct. 23, 2025A related appeal to the county Board of Adjustment over a will-serve letter is "withdrawn from consideration" (Dec. 11, 2025 packet).
- 2026District board agendas list closed sessions on "Imminent Legal Action" with no detail.
What each side says
| Question | Developers (alleged) | Water district (argued) |
|---|---|---|
| Did the district block the projects? | The district "believes and intends to act on the belief that the District does not have a legal duty" to provide service (complaint, per Building Salt Lake). | It has only one culinary source and has been "tirelessly attempting to add sources" (statement). |
| What about the water shares? | The case "challenges, among other things, the District's unlawful exaction of WCIC shares" (Sept. 8, 2025 letter). | "Having negotiated contracts with defendant, plaintiffs can't now complain that they got precisely what they bargained for" (motion, as reported). |
What court rulings and records confirm
- The case is Second District Civil No. 250903485 (Board of Adjustment packet).
- The district moved to dismiss on June 13, 2025 (KSL/Deseret).
- No ruling, settlement or 2026 news coverage was found.
Claims no court has decided
These are what a party says in its filings. They are not findings.
- The developers allege the district improperly required water shares and blocked development. No court has decided this.
- Dollar figures ($19.5 million, $45 million, $54.5 million) come from news reports and letters, not from any court ruling.
What the district told its customers (March 10, 2026)
The district's board sent customers a letter on March 10, 2026. It is the district's own account, not a court finding. It says:
- Developers have brought three lawsuits against the district and are also suing Eden Waterworks Company and the State Engineer. A fourth suit challenges the State Engineer's rejection of a developer well (EC5).
- One suit says the district didn't give enough water credit for Wolf Creek Irrigation Company shares; a second similar suit is by a different developer; a third says some district spring water rights are no longer valid.
- The district serves 1,344 homes; developers want more than 700 new connections inside the district and 400 more outside it.
- The district says it has spent about $12 million since 2020 on water supply, and is "currently spending around $30 to $40K per month" on legal and hydrology work.
- To pay for it, customers' bills include a $25 a month "legal defense fee", after a public hearing in September 2025, starting in November 2025.
Because the letter describes several separate suits, this page focuses on Case No. 250903485 and lists the others as related.
People connected to the record
What we don't know yet
- The judge assigned.
- Whether the motion to dismiss was decided.
- The full list of plaintiffs.
- Whether the case has settled.
- The earlier lawsuit the district's statement called "additional."
Questions to ask, and whom to ask
- Wolf Creek Water and Sewer Improvement District board: How many new connections can the Warm Springs well support, and what new sources are planned?
- Wolf Creek Water and Sewer Improvement District board: How much has the $25 legal defense fee raised so far, and how much has been spent on the lawsuits?
- Weber County Commission: Should building approvals in Ogden Valley require a confirmed water source first?
- Second District Court (docket): What is the status of Civil No. 250903485?
Words to know
Help cover records costs
Public records aren't always free. The Hive Records Fund helps pay records fees, copies and other costs behind pages like this one. You pick the amount, and every dollar in and every cost paid is listed publicly. The Weber County Hive is not a nonprofit, so contributions are not tax-deductible.
Behind this piece
Built from court records and news reports listed below.
Sources
Sources — click to open (with links)
- KSL: Ogden Valley developer suing water district (May 9, 2025)
- Building Salt Lake (June 18, 2025)
- KSL/Deseret: second developer sues (July 3, 2025)
- Weber County Board of Adjustment packet, Oct. 23, 2025
- Weber County Board of Adjustment packet, Dec. 11, 2025
- Wolf Creek Water and Sewer Improvement District: legal update letter to customers (March 10, 2026), read in the browser

