Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveThe people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not any party or special interest.
← All Government in Court cases  ·  Hive library ↗Government in Court · Court records

CASE FILE · GOVERNMENT IN COURT · UTAH ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE · GC 001

Seized, held for two and a half years, then missing: the Rubicon evidence lawsuit

A Bountiful company and its owners say the Utah Attorney General's Office lost a box of original papers and four USB drives it seized in a 2023 raid. The state's case against them was dismissed, and federal prosecutors declined to bring charges. The Attorney General's Office says the items went missing while federal agents had legal custody, and it has asked the court to dismiss the suit.

Court: Third District, Salt Lake CountyCase No. 260907235Filed Sept. 15, 2026Status: motion to dismiss reported filed Nov. 4

Posted Nov. 6, 2026

WHERE · WHO
Utah Attorney General's Office · Third District Court (Salt Lake) · Second District Court (Davis) · U.S. District Court (Utah)

In plain words (explain it like I'm 10)

In 2023, state investigators searched a company's offices and took boxes of papers and computer drives. They said the owners were mistreating foreign workers. The state case never went to trial. A judge dropped it in 2025 when the state asked, and federal prosecutors later decided not to charge anyone. When it came time to hand the seized things over, one box of papers and four USB drives could not be found. Now the owners are suing the Attorney General's Office. They want the things back, or an explanation and money. The Attorney General's Office says federal agents were in charge of the evidence when it went missing, and it wants the judge to throw the case out. Nobody has been found guilty of anything. A judge has not decided this lawsuit.

The short version

Nov. 20, 2023raid on Rubicon's offices
Feb. 2025state case dismissed (without prejudice)
April 8, 2026DOJ declines to charge
1 box + 4 drivesmissing as of May 21, 2026

Timeline

Dates from court filings and news coverage listed in Sources.

What a Franks hearing is

Before police can search a place, an officer swears to a judge, in writing, why there is good reason to search. A Franks hearing (named for the 1978 U.S. Supreme Court case Franks v. Delaware) is when the person who was searched asks the judge to check whether that sworn statement told the truth. If the officer knowingly lied or left out key facts, and the warrant would not have been approved without them, the search can be thrown out.

A judge only grants the hearing after a "substantial showing" that something may be wrong. Granting the hearing is not a ruling that the statements were false.

What Judge Cornish wrote (as reported by KSL, July 19, 2024)The defense made a "substantial showing" that the agent's statements were "knowingly false or at a minimum made with a reckless disregard for the truth," and the affidavits may be "replete with false and misleading statements."
What the defendants' Feb. 11, 2026 federal motion saysThe complaint does not allege that the evidentiary hearing occurred, so the judge "did not determine whether any of the statements in the affidavits actually were false."

The complaint quotes the ruling as saying it is "possible, perhaps even probable" that the affidavits are "replete with false and misleading statements." In one place (¶ 55) the complaint drops the "possible, perhaps even probable" part. This page keeps it.

What each side says

QuestionThe Larsens (complaint, Sept. 15, 2026)The AG's Office (motion, Nov. 4, 2026, as reported)
Who had the evidence?It stayed in the AG's own locker the whole time; HSI had legal custody on paper only.HSI held it from December 2024 until May 21, 2026.
What went missing?A box of original papers and four USB drives, with the data on them."Certain items were missing, including a box of papers and four USB storage drives."
Who should be sued?The AG's Office, which seized and stored it.HSI is not named as a defendant.
Is it too early?The case is over, so the property must be returned now.The office can keep evidence until the statute of limitations runs, so a loss claim is "premature."
Must the office explain?Asks for a sworn accounting of what happened.It has no duty to give an "accounting."
What is the claim?Negligent loss of seized property (Utah Code § 77-11b-204) and a declaration and accounting.Asks the court to dismiss.

The AG's Office's motion is described from ABC4's report of it. The Hive has not read the motion itself.

Who had the evidence? The two records that disagree

Both can be partly true: the complaint itself says HSI had legal custody after the December 2024 federal warrant, while the items sat in an AG's Office locker. What the records don't show yet is when the items were last seen, who opened that locker, and whether the federal agent's sworn return listed every item. The complaint says three of the four drives never appeared on the federal inventory (¶ 40).

What records and reporting confirm

What is only alleged (not decided by any court)

These come from the complaint and the Notice of Claim. They are the Larsens' claims.

The program and its funding

The case came out of the AG's SECURE Strike Force, a unit in its Criminal Investigations Division. The Legislature created it in 2009 (complaint, ¶ 72, citing H.B. 64, 2009).

The complaint says federal grant awards in September 2024 sent $999,994 to the AG's Office and $949,999 to the Asian Association of Utah. The Hive confirmed the first award on the federal OVC site: 15POVC-24-GK-01059-HT, $999,994, for the Utah Trafficking in Persons Task Force. The second award has not been checked yet.

Whether this case was used to win funding is the Larsens' claim. The award pages do not mention it.

People connected to the record

Derek BrownUtah Attorney General (since Jan. 2025)Named in the complaint "for context." Not a defendant in this case. His name is on the AG's Feb. 2026 federal motion.
Sean ReyesFormer Utah Attorney GeneralDefendant in the $1 billion federal suit, which says he has immunity.
Kaytlin V. BeckettAssistant attorney general; former special assistant U.S. attorneyDrafted the warrant affidavits (complaint). Defendant in the federal suit; target of a sanctions motion. Signed the May 4, 2026 declaration quoted in the complaint.
Michael Adam JeterSECURE investigatorSigned the warrant affidavits (complaint). Defendant in the federal suit.
Leo LuceyChief, Criminal Investigations DivisionDefendant in the federal suit.
Stewart M. YoungCriminal Deputy Attorney GeneralNamed "for context"; not a defendant.
Bradley R. BlackhamAssistant attorney generalCounsel for the AG's Office in the federal suit; named "for context."
Jared HatchHSI special agentSwore the federal warrant affidavit and return; target of the June 2026 sanctions motion.
Rita M. CornishSecond District judgeGranted the Franks hearing and dismissed the state case without prejudice.
Heather BreretonThird District judgeAssigned to this lawsuit.

What we don't know yet

  • When the box and the four drives were last seen, and by whom.
  • Whether the AG's Office's evidence log ("Versaterm Evidence Continuity," per the complaint) shows a checkout with no return.
  • Whether any copy or image of the drives' data exists.
  • Whether the Franks hearing was ever held. The defense's federal motion says the complaint doesn't allege it was.
  • How the judge ruled at the preliminary hearing, if she did, before the case was dismissed.
  • Whether the second federal grant ($949,999 to the Asian Association of Utah) matches the complaint.
  • How the judges will rule on the motions to dismiss in this case and the federal case.

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

  1. The Utah Legislature's Judiciary and Law Enforcement committees: What rules require state agencies to log, store and return seized property, and who checks that they follow them?
  2. The Legislative Auditor General: Has any audit looked at how the AG's Office tracks seized evidence since the January 2025 audits?
  3. The Attorney General's Office (public records): What written policy does the office have for storing seized property, as Utah Code § 77-11a-204 requires?
  4. Third District Court (court docket): When is the hearing on the AG's motion to dismiss?
  5. Readers: When an agency seizes property and a case ends without charges, how long should it take to get the property back?

Words to know

Help cover records costs

Public records aren't always free. The Hive Records Fund helps pay records fees, copies and other costs behind pages like this one. You pick the amount, and every dollar in and every cost paid is listed publicly. The Weber County Hive is not a nonprofit, so contributions are not tax-deductible.

Give to the Records FundSee the public ledger →

Behind this piece

54
pages of court filings read
17
news reports and records checked
4
related court cases tracked
2
sworn statements compared

A tip came in with the complaint and its attachments. The Hive never names tipsters.

Sources

Sources — click to open (with links)
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism

The Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.

Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us

We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.

Government in Court shelf · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack