- Who is suing: Mango-Spiral Jetty, LLC. Its registered agent is Matthew Garff, co-owner of the Ken Garff Automotive Group (Salt Lake Tribune).
- Who is being sued: State Engineer Teresa Wilhelmsen and the Division of Water Rights.
- The judge: Brandon Maynard, First District Court (summons).
- Lawyers: Sen. Brady Brammer and his firm, Brammer Ranck (Salt Lake Tribune). The firm declined to comment.
- What it is about: 1,260 acre-feet of groundwater for mining and ranching on a 5,300-acre ranch less than 2 miles from the shoreline.
In plain words (explain it like I'm 10)
In Utah you need the state's permission to pump groundwater. A big ranch near the Great Salt Lake asked for a lot of water. The state said no to most of it, worried that one owner would control too much of a small supply. The ranch says the state approved similar requests nearby, so the denial was unfair. A judge hasn't decided yet.
The short version
- The request: 1,260 acre-feet: 300 for mining and the rest for ranching (Salt Lake Tribune). A lithium company, Waterleaf Phase 1, wrote that it intends to lease the water (Dec. 5, 2025 letter).
- The decision: The State Engineer denied all but one application, approving 240 acre-feet for irrigation. She cited a "concern of monopolization of a limited resource" and an area whose hydrology is "poorly understood."
- The lawsuit (Jan. 8, 2026): alleges the decision "acted contrary to statute, ignored substantial and significant evidence" and was arbitrary, and that nearby applications "mere minutes away" were approved.
- Keller Cattle: According to the Salt Lake Tribune, the suit lists water right numbers belonging to Keller Cattle Corporation, linked to Speaker Mike Schultz, but does not name him. The Hive has not read the full petition to confirm this.
Timeline
Dates from court records and news coverage listed in Sources.
flowchart TD A["July 2024
Keller Cattle application
approved (550+ acre-feet)"] --> B["Dec. 5, 2025
Lithium company support
letter for Mango"] B --> C["Late 2025
State Engineer denies
most Mango applications"] C --> D["Jan. 8, 2026
Mango sues in
First District Court"] D --> E["No ruling found"]
- 2019Mango-Spiral Jetty LLC registers in Utah (Salt Lake Tribune).
- July 2024Keller Cattle Corporation's 2023 application for more than 550 acre-feet is approved over protests by Utah Rivers Council and Farmland Reserve (Salt Lake Tribune).
- Dec. 5, 2025Waterleaf Phase 1 (a Lilac Solutions subsidiary) writes in support of applications 13-4105 and 13-4106 for lithium extraction.
- Before Jan. 8, 2026State Engineer denies all but 240 acre-feet.
- Jan. 8, 2026Mango files its petition, First District Court, Box Elder County, Case No. 260100003, Judge Brandon Maynard (summons; Salt Lake Tribune).
- Jan. 26, 2026Salt Lake Tribune and Grist report the case.
What each side says
| Question | Mango-Spiral Jetty (petition, as quoted) | State Engineer / Division of Water Rights |
|---|---|---|
| Was the denial fair? | The engineer "failed to adequately support its decision" and acted arbitrarily. | A spokesperson said the state is "confident" its decision was fair, consistent and appropriate (Salt Lake Tribune). |
| Monopoly concern | The concern is speculative because 1,260 acre-feet is "only a fraction" of available water. | Six back-to-back applications "raises a concern of monopolization of a limited resource." |
| Nearby approvals | Applications "mere minutes away" were approved despite similar protests. | Remaining water in the area is "limited" and the hydrology "poorly understood." |
What court rulings and records confirm
- The case is First District Court, Box Elder County, No. 260100003, Judge Brandon Maynard (summons posted by the Division of Water Rights; the Hive read the summons page only, not the full petition).
- The State Engineer approved 240 acre-feet for irrigation and denied the rest (Salt Lake Tribune).
- Keller Cattle's application for more than 550 acre-feet was approved in July 2024 (Salt Lake Tribune).
Claims no court has decided
These are what a party says in its filings. They are not findings.
- Mango alleges the State Engineer applied different standards to its applications than to nearby ones. No court has decided this.
People connected to the record
Where this connects
- Great Salt Lake water votes (GSL-Votes repo)Lawmakers' Great Salt Lake and water records.
What we don't know yet
- The state's written answer to the petition.
- Any hearing date or ruling.
- The date of the State Engineer's denial.
- Whether the lithium lease plan is still in place.
Questions to ask, and whom to ask
- Division of Water Rights: What standard decides when several applications from one owner raise a monopoly concern?
- Legislative Natural Resources committees: How much groundwater remains available on the Promontory peninsula, and who measures it?
- First District Court (docket): When is the next hearing in Case No. 260100003?
Words to know
Help cover records costs
Public records aren't always free. The Hive Records Fund helps pay records fees, copies and other costs behind pages like this one. You pick the amount, and every dollar in and every cost paid is listed publicly. The Weber County Hive is not a nonprofit, so contributions are not tax-deductible.
Behind this piece
Built from court records and news reports listed below.

