- Who is suing: Alliance for a Better Utah and Jane Does 1-5 (Box Elder County residents). Better Utah's case page also lists Saline Now, Inc. and another unnamed nonprofit.
- Who is being sued: MIDA, Sen. J. Stuart Adams, Sen. Jerry Stevenson and the Box Elder County Commission.
- Lawyers: David R. Irvine (Bountiful) and Alan L. Smith (Salt Lake City), for the plaintiffs.
- What it is about: Whether MIDA, with sitting legislators on its board, can exercise taxing and land-use powers over the Stratos project area.
In plain words (explain it like I'm 10)
MIDA is a state authority run by an appointed board, not by voters. Two of its board members were sitting state senators. The people suing say the Utah Constitution doesn't let lawmakers also sit on a board like that, and doesn't let an unelected board use powers like taxing. They want a judge to say so and stop the Stratos data center plan. No judge has ruled yet.
The short version
- Filed: June 3, 2026, in Third District Court. The case number and judge are blank on the public copy of the complaint.
- Ten claims, including Art. VI §6 (legislators holding another office) and Art. VI §28 (giving taxing or city powers to a special commission).
- What they ask: declare the MIDA act and actions void, permanently block the Stratos Project Area Plan, declare Adams and Stevenson "unconstitutional appointees," and order Adams to "disgorge monies."
- Status: KSL/Deseret reported Oct. 2, 2026, that the defendants "hadn't yet responded." The Hive has not checked the docket since. An amended complaint was filed Sept. 28 (Better Utah).
Timeline
Dates from court records and news coverage listed in Sources.
flowchart TD A["June 3, 2026
Complaint filed"] --> B["June 2026
Adams loses SD-7 primary"] B --> C["Aug. 2026
Gov. Cox: MIDA needs
major reform"] C --> D["Sept. 28, 2026
Amended complaint"] D --> E["Oct. 2, 2026
No response yet
from defendants"]
- June 3, 2026Complaint filed in Third District Court (complaint).
- June 4, 2026Better Utah announces the suit; MIDA says it hadn't reviewed the complaint; Box Elder County says it will "evaluate the matter and respond as appropriate" (Salt Lake Tribune).
- June 2026Sen. Adams loses the SD-7 Republican primary to Stephanie Hollist. MIDA board members "serve at the pleasure of their appointing authority" (TownLift).
- Aug. 21, 2026Gov. Cox: "I think we need major reform when it comes to MIDA" (Utah News Dispatch via TownLift).
- Sept. 28, 2026Amended complaint filed (Better Utah case page, updated Sept. 30).
- Oct. 2, 2026Defendants "hadn't yet responded"; O'Leary Digital's CEO says "The project is not on hold" (KSL/Deseret).
What each side says
| Question | Plaintiffs (complaint) | Defendants |
|---|---|---|
| Is MIDA's board lawful? | Alleges sitting legislators on the board violate Art. VI §6 and §9. | No filed response found. |
| Can MIDA use these powers? | Alleges giving taxing and municipal powers to a special commission violates Art. VI §28. | No filed response found. |
| Public statements | "MIDA is an unelected body exercising powers the Utah Constitution never authorized" (Better Utah). | MIDA: no comment because it "hadn't had a chance to review the legal complaint" (Salt Lake Tribune). |
What court rulings and records confirm
- The complaint was filed June 3, 2026, by attorneys David R. Irvine and Alan L. Smith (complaint).
- Named defendants: MIDA, Stuart Adams, Jerry Stevenson and the Box Elder County Commission. The State of Utah is not named (complaint).
- No motions or rulings were reported as of Oct. 2, 2026 (KSL/Deseret; Better Utah case page, status date Sept. 30). This does not show there has been no response since.
Claims no court has decided
These are what a party says in its filings. They are not findings.
- The complaint alleges ten violations, including abridging direct and representative democracy rights, unconstitutional board composition, Art. VI §28 and §29 violations, non-compliance with the MIDA Act, and breach of fiduciary duty.
- Better Utah alleges "Adams accepted $135,000 as a PAC donation from MIDA contractors days after the county greenlit the project." No court has decided this.
People connected to the record
Where this connects
- Stratos and MIDA files (Data-Centers repo)The project this lawsuit asks a court to stop.
What we don't know yet
- The case number and assigned judge.
- What the Sept. 28 amended complaint added.
- Who represents the defendants, and when they must respond.
- Whether Adams still sits on the MIDA board.
- The status of the separate BEAR referendum case in First District Court.
Questions to ask, and whom to ask
- The Legislature's Government Operations committees: Should sitting legislators serve on boards like MIDA that their own bills created or expanded?
- MIDA: Who now holds the board seats tied to the Senate, and when does each term end?
- Box Elder County Commission: Has the county answered the complaint, and who is paying for its defense?
Words to know
Help cover records costs
Public records aren't always free. The Hive Records Fund helps pay records fees, copies and other costs behind pages like this one. You pick the amount, and every dollar in and every cost paid is listed publicly. The Weber County Hive is not a nonprofit, so contributions are not tax-deductible.
Behind this piece
Built from court records and news reports listed below.
Sources
Sources — click to open (with links)
- Complaint, Alliance for a Better Utah et al. v. MIDA et al. (June 3, 2026), hosted by KJZZ
- Better Utah: MIDA lawsuit case page (updated Sept. 30, 2026)
- Better Utah press release (June 4, 2026)
- Salt Lake Tribune (June 4, 2026)
- KSL/Deseret News (Oct. 2, 2026)
- TownLift: Adams could retain MIDA role (June 29, 2026)
- TownLift/Utah News Dispatch: Cox says MIDA needs major reform (Aug. 21, 2026)

